Team

How We Work

How We Work

Our reasons for becoming insurance professionals are deeply personal. We repeatedly saw friends and family struggling to find the coverage they needed. We are confident that with our understanding of the insurance space, we can help people better prepare for the future. After years in the business, we have developed a reputation for educating individuals in an easy-to-understand manner, so they can easily grasp personal insurance concepts. Above all else, we feel a commitment to our community.

Our team approach adds perspective and provides increased benefits to our clients.

Meet Our Team

Mark Stolly, CPCU, CIC, CRM

Business | Personal

mark.stolly@stolly.com

Mark E. Stolly, CPCU, CIC, CRM, is a fourth generation member of the five generation family-owned agency. Founded in 1904 by his great grandfather A.A. Stolly, SIG provides commercial, personal, life and benefits insurance solutions to...

Read more

Tim Stolly, CIC, CPCU, LUTCF

Business | Personal | Life

tim.stolly@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Commercial, Personal, Life, Annuity, Disability, and Long-Term Care Insurance. Education / Designations: Graduate of Lima Central Catholic HS in 1975. Graduated with a Business Administrative Degree from the...
Read more

William Stolly, CPCU

Business | Personal

william.stolly@stolly.com

Bill began his career in 1979 with the Continental Insurance Company in NY, NY. He then became a commercial broker with the NY firm Walter Kaye and Associates in 1982. He joined the Stolly Insurance Group in the fall of 1984. His...
Read more

Kevin Stolly, CPCU, ChFC, AIM

Business | Personal

kevin.stolly@stolly.com

Position: Agency President, Commercial and Personal Lines Agent. Education / Designations: Bachelor of Business Administration, St John’s University, New York City, NY. College of Insurance 1992. Associate in Insurance Management...

Read more

Jon Wade, CIC

Business | Personal

jon.wade@stolly.com

Position: Sales Manager, Life and Health Department Manager, Commercial and Personal Lines Agent. Education / Designations: Jon studied business at Ohio State University and holds the Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation....
Read more

Peter Stolly, CIC

Business | Personal

peter.stolly@stolly.com

Peter helps clients with both Commercial and Personal Insurance needs. He has 20+ years of experience working with municipalities, school district and a variety of commercial business clients. He also serves as Lake Township Trustee,...

Read more

Adam Stolly, CIC

Business | Personal | Life

adam.stolly@stolly.com

Adam helps clients with both their business and personal insurance needs. He has experience working in the personal asset protection for high net worth customer as well as working with business owners on risk management strategies in...
Read more

Jason Stolly, CPCU, CIC, CRM

Business | Personal | Life

jason.stolly@stolly.com

Jason is a seasoned insurance professional with comprehensive knowledge and expertise in multiple areas of property and casualty insurance. Throughout his career, Jason has held various positions in the insurance industry including...

Read more

Allison Whitacre

Business | Personal

allison.whitacre@stolly.com

Allison has a passion for safeguarding what matters most. She specializes in tailoring solutions for your business insurance needs ranging from rentals properties, restaurants, foods trucks, construction companies, and trucking...
Read more

Amanda Guetschow

Account Manager

Barb Omlor, CISR

Account Manager

Barb is currently specializing in personal property and casualty insurance at Stolly. Barb and husband Doug love spending time with their family, especially their 2 grandchildren. In her spare time Barb enjoys reading, crosswords &...

Beth Apple

Account Manager

Brenda Sharp

Account Manager

Brenda specializes in commercial insurance. She loves spending time with her husband Steve, and family and friends. Brenda’s favorite past times are reading, gardening, and going hiking, camping or anything outdoors.

Britney McElroy

Account Manager

Britney is an Account Manager specializing in the Life and Health Department. In her free time she enjoys spending time with her son Maxton, cheering him on at his sporting events and traveling to family friendly destinations.

Brittany Beckstedt, ACSR

Account Manager

Brittany is an Account Manager specializing in the Personal Lines Department. She and her husband have 2 boys, Raylon & Gunnar. As a Celina native herself, she looks forward to building a strong relationship with their customers.

Chad Stolly, CIC

Business | Personal | Life

chad.stolly@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Commercial, Personal, and Life Insurance. Education / Designations: Bachelor of Science in Education from Bowling Green State University, Certified Insurance Counselor from the National Alliance. Description: Chad...
Read more

Cheyenne Lopez, RHU, ACBC

Employee Benefits

cheyenne.lopez@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Employee Benefits, Personal healthcare and Life Insurance.Education / Designations: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from University of Northwestern Ohio, Registered Health Underwriter (RHU) from the...
Read more

Daniel Brookman, LUTCF

Business | Personal | Life

daniel.brookman@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Commercial, Personal, Life, Annuity, Disability, and Long-Term Care Insurance. Education / Designations: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from Franklin University, Life Underwriter Training Council...
Read more

Danielle McMaken

Account Manager

Danielle is an Account Manager specializing in Individual Life & Health. Danielle and her husband share 8 children and 7 grandchildren. She enjoys home improvement, decorating and cheering on THE Ohio State Buckeyes!!!

Danna Koch

Account Manager

Danna has 3 grown children, Caleb married to Stacy , Amanda married to David, and Hannah married to Adam. She currently has 3 grandchildren Joanna, Cole, and James. In her past time out of work she likes to spend her time with her...

Denise Pohl

Vice President of Finance

Denise is supervisor of the Administration department, and acting Vice President of Finance, which includes the accounting and automation functions of the agency.

Eric Stolly, CPCU, AU, AINS, ChFC

Business | Personal

eric.stolly@stolly.com

Eric focuses on helping a wide variety businesses and organizations, as well as families and individuals with their insurance and risk management planning. Eric has extensive experience in the insurance industry including claims...
Read more

Hannah Jacobs

Account Manager

Hannah is an Account Manager specializing in the Life and Health Department.

Heather Donley

System Administrator

Heather is the Systems Administrator for the agency and is responsible for maintaining the agency computer equipment and providing staff automation training. She is currently the treasurer for U-VU Ohio which is an Ohio Users Group...

Jacob Stolly

Business | Personal

Jacob.stolly@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Commercial and Personal Insurance. Education / Designations: Associates Degree in Law Enforcement from Rhodes State College. Description: Jacob helps clients with both their business and personal property and...
Read more

Jamie Williams, CPIW,ACSR,CISR

Account Manager

Jamie specializes in the Commercial Lines Department. Jamie and her husband, Jeff, have one daughter, Jordan. Her interests outside the office include spending time with her family, shopping and traveling.

Jarod Stolly, CIC

Business | Personal

jarod.stolly@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Commercial and Personal Insurance. Wapakoneta Office Branch Manager. Education / Designations: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from Mount St. Joseph University. Certified Insurance Councilor (CIC)...
Read more

Jenni Henry

Account Manager

Jenni is an Account Manager specializing in the Life and Health Department, she also supervises the Life and Health Department. Jenni enjoys living at Indian Lake. In her free time she love spending time with friends, family and...

Joel Stolly, CIC

Business | Personal | Life

joel.stolly@stolly.com

Joel is a licensed agent specializing in property and casualty insurance. He holds a Certified Insurance Counselor designation in addition to licenses in Property & Casualty, Disability, Life, and Health insurance. Joel enjoys helping...

Read more

Jordan Martin

Employee Benefits

jordan.martin@stolly.com

Jordan works with businesses to provide employee benefit offerings to their staff. With experience in self-funding, fully insured and MEWA arrangements Jordan is equipped to help businesses of any size.
Read more

Julie Jordan, AIM, CPIW, MLIS

Vice President of Human Resources

Julie started with Stolly Insurance Group in 1977 working part time after school. Over the years, she has held various titles including Customer Service Rep, Supervisor and her present position of Office Administrator. Julie is a...

Kathy Luersman, CSRM, AIC, AINS, AIS, CPIW

Claims

Kathy is the manager of the property and casualty claims department. Kathy and her husband, Dave, spend most of their time at their four children’s sporting events. She also enjoys reading, crochet, and Ohio State football.

Kelly Falor

Receptionist

Kelly works in our administrative department as the front receptionist at our Wapakoneta office. Kelly and her late husband, Kevin, have two children and one grandchild. Kelly enjoys baking, crafts, remodeling homes, and spending time...

Leanne Daggett

Account Manager

Lisa Sheipline, RHU,ACBC

Employee Benefits

lisa.sheipline@stolly.com

Lisa specializes in Group Benefits, health insurance, life insurance, annuity, disability and Long-Term Care Insurance. With over 30 years of experience, she has the expertise and skills to offer the most innovative and comprehensive...
Read more

Lisa Haidle, CISR, ACSR

Account Manager

Lisa specializes in personal insurance. Lisa has four children and one grandchild. She enjoys spending time with her family and friends, antiquing, and watching her youngest son’s sporting events.

Luana Anderson

Receptionist

Marcus Simpson

Personal

marcus.simpson@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Personal Lines Education / Designations: Attended the University of Northwestern Ohio. Description: Marcus joined Stolly Insurance Group in 2022 and is licensed in both property & casualty as well as life...

Read more

Martha Mullins, CISR

Account Manager

Martha joined the Stolly Insurance family in April, 2003. She has been in the insurance business since 1986 and specializes in marketing personal lines business. Martha and her husband, Matt, love cheering on The Ohio State Buckeye...

Matt Johnston

Employee Benefits | Senior Products

matt.johnston@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Individual and Group Health, Medicare, Life, Annuity, Disability, and Long- Term Care Insurance.Education / Designations: Bachelor of Science in Management from the University of PhoenixDescription: Matt takes great...
Read more

Mindy Hesseling, CISR, ACSR

Account Manager

Mindy specializes in the Commercial Lines Department and is the Department Supervisor. Prior to coming to Stolly, she worked at a local independent insurance agency. Her interests outside the office include spending time with her...

Missy Tidd

Account Manager

Missy specializes in the Commercial Lines Department. Missy and her husband, Sean, have two children. Her interests include spending time with her family, attending sporting events, and traveling.

Patrick Stolly, AINS, AU, CIC

Business | Personal | Life

patrick.stolly@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Commercial, Personal, and Life Insurance.Education / Designations: Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from Capital University, Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) Associate in Commercial Underwriting...
Read more

Samantha Fletcher

Account Manager

Samantha specializes in the Commercial Insurance Department. She and her husband Kory have 2 sons, Kamden & Kalvin, who keeps them on their toes! In her free time, Samantha enjoys traveling, crafting, shopping, and cooking.

Sandy Miles, ACSR

Account Manager

Sandy specializes in the Personal Lines Department. She and her husband, Mark, share four children. Sandy enjoys cooking, reading, Steelers football, and spending time with her family.

Sue Meeker

Account Manager

Sue specializes in the commercial lines department. Sue and her husband Bill share 5 children that keep them busy by following them in sports. She enjoys bowling, reading, and being at home with their kids and her husband.

Terra Henkle, CIC

Business | Personal | Life

terra.henkle@stolly.com

Position: Agent for Commercial, Personal, and Life Insurance Products. Education / Designations: Studied at Marshall University and Ohio University, Certified Insurance Counselor since 2015. Description: Terra has the desire to help...
Read more